#2 is basically how I setup my big tank with the 80g display macro tank and the 210g cryptic fuge tank. The DT gravity drains to both of them, and the macro tank gravity drains to the big fuge. The 210 is packed with tons of live rock which all the water is forced to flow through and then external pump to push it back to DT.
I had originally planned to use a horse trough too, but decided to go with a standard 210g tank because, for one, it would be very difficult to make dividers for the horse trough, and also because evaporation would be much harder to handle. The 210 made better use of the space under my stairs too. The trough likely would have increased the humidity levels by quite a bit as well. With the 210g I was able to make a cover that is hooked to some fresh air supply so that evap is easier to control and I can keep room humidity down.
I had originally planned to use a horse trough too, but decided to go with a standard 210g tank because, for one, it would be very difficult to make dividers for the horse trough, and also because evaporation would be much harder to handle. The 210 made better use of the space under my stairs too. The trough likely would have increased the humidity levels by quite a bit as well. With the 210g I was able to make a cover that is hooked to some fresh air supply so that evap is easier to control and I can keep room humidity down.