QT questions

ShelbyJK500

Dolphin
M.A.S.C Club Member
#1
I'm not having much luck ordering fish, specifically Angels all at once. I got one QT tank and will probably be getting another this weekend to keep at least two in each tank during QT since I'll probably just start piecing my "fish list" together.

SO, this is my first run at doing QT. First what is the best level for hypo-salinity, and is it necessary as a prophylactic treatment or only after a sickness has been observed? Second, I plan on doing Prazipro right off the bat...who carries it? Lastly, who runs copper or cupermine as a prophylactic? Is it necessary, again, if the fish show no sign of sickness?

Maybe I should just ask what the consensus is on what should be used prophylacticly and what should be saved until a sickness is observed?


Here's my first setup...more to come I'm thinking.

 

jagermeister

Blenny
M.A.S.C Club Member
#3
I've never treated with hypo or copper without visible signs of an illness. Both can be pretty harsh on the fish. I do, however, prazipro all fish in qt. I'm pretty sure About Fish on Federal stocks Prazipro.
 

ShelbyJK500

Dolphin
M.A.S.C Club Member
#4
jagermeister;143500 said:
I've never treated with hypo or copper without visible signs of an illness. Both can be pretty harsh on the fish. I do, however, prazipro all fish in qt. I'm pretty sure About Fish on Federal stocks Prazipro.
Thanks for the input! That seems to be the consensus I've been finding with maintenance companies and many of our sponsors. I've heard from people in business that they have had more success and fewer losses than the days of just treating everything right up front. It doesn't hurt that many are obtaining fish from places like Quality Marine, where the stock is in good health to begin with. Thanks again for the info, I'll hit up About Fish tomorrow.
 

djkms

Reef Shark
M.A.S.C Club Member
#7
ShelbyJK500;143714 said:
I tried Premier. I've tried several places.
The issue is 2 fold. Angels typically don't do well together unless they are in large systems and even then its iffy at best. Sure there are plenty of videos and pics of angels together on the net but this is usually the exception not the rule. The problem we have as a shop is the amount of quarantine tanks we have. IIRC you wanted a few angels and because each angel has to be separated during QT this really limits the amount we can get for you.

The second issue is supply (and this will hold true with any fish store or retail outlet). I know for us (Premier) we are not a retail outlet exclusively so when we do order fish we only order from 1 supplier at a time because we do not sell in enough volume to warrant orders from multiple wholesalers. Unfortunately we are at the mercy of what fish are in stock at the wholesale level. Typically fish availability comes in waves, one week there will be over 100 of one specimen available while there are 0 available of another. The stock changes daily, even by the minute with Quality Marine because they supply fish to hundreds, if not thousands of retail outlets.

As I am sure you are aware, the trick with Angels is if you do plan on adding multiple specimens to a system its best to add them all at the same time so dominance and territory are not predetermined. This is very very difficult to accomplish unless you really have good gameplan and don't depend on one source for your fish. If there is a store locally or online who can in fact provide all the angels your looking for in one shot by all means I would hop on it! Its not that we don't want to help you, we just don't have the capacity to do so.

That being said we are doing a fish order this week so PM me a list of what you are looking for and I will talk it over with Will to see what we can do.

Thanks,
Kris
 

ShelbyJK500

Dolphin
M.A.S.C Club Member
#8
djkms;143735 said:
The issue is 2 fold. Angels typically don't do well together unless they are in large systems and even then its iffy at best. Sure there are plenty of videos and pics of angels together on the net but this is usually the exception not the rule. The problem we have as a shop is the amount of quarantine tanks we have. IIRC you wanted a few angels and because each angel has to be separated during QT this really limits the amount we can get for you.

The second issue is supply (and this will hold true with any fish store or retail outlet). I know for us (Premier) we are not a retail outlet exclusively so when we do order fish we only order from 1 supplier at a time because we do not sell in enough volume to warrant orders from multiple wholesalers. Unfortunately we are at the mercy of what fish are in stock at the wholesale level. Typically fish availability comes in waves, one week there will be over 100 of one specimen available while there are 0 available of another. The stock changes daily, even by the minute with Quality Marine because they supply fish to hundreds, if not thousands of retail outlets.

As I am sure you are aware, the trick with Angels is if you do plan on adding multiple specimens to a system its best to add them all at the same time so dominance and territory are not predetermined. This is very very difficult to accomplish unless you really have good gameplan and don't depend on one source for your fish. If there is a store locally or online who can in fact provide all the angels your looking for in one shot by all means I would hop on it! Its not that we don't want to help you, we just don't have the capacity to do so.

That being said we are doing a fish order this week so PM me a list of what you are looking for and I will talk it over with Will to see what we can do.

Thanks,
Kris
Hey Kris,

Figured I would reply since you took the time to do so. First, I've beat this "mixing angels" topic to death. There are more than a few exceptions-to-the-rule going on out there, as observed on the national forums, youtube, etc. I've lightly researched over the past 8 months and more heavily the last month, this topic to the point of exhaustion. After all, Angel's and corals are truly what got me into the hobby.

Will had some great advise and direction in this venture. I have and continue to be completely flexible with advice and suggestions as I haven't been doing this for 20 years. That said, my list has already changed with even more research and speaking with other experienced wholesalers, suppliers, LFS's and maintenance companies. I'm not one of those wealthy, out-of-touch hobbiest's who approach this with demands instead of desires. ;) For example, the Imperator is off the list as it's one of the "alpha" angels.

I only have two points of frustration. First, you mentioned not having the capacity to do this, and the unlikely ability through suppliers. I wish I would've known/been told this a month ago. I would have had a month jump on finding other avenues. I've consistently seen 3 out of the 4 on my "list" in LFS's over the past month, so I didn't figure finding the supply would be the issue. I was concerned with finding like-sizes. Though the LFS's consistently had like-sizes. I continually passed on picking any of these up because I thought the order was going to be possible. My understanding was the issue became, medicating clients fish, and as such not having room at the moment for this order. That I can understand, but still wish I would've known a bit sooner.

Second, you mentioned to me last week that it was likely you all wouldn't be doing an order for another couple of months. That combined with the medicating of client's fish...the suggestion was made to possibly explore other avenues. That's when I decided to move on. Now there is an order going on? I'm confused. Doesn't that require room for anyone ordering fish for the 2 week QT period? Maybe I just don't understand all the cogs in the wheel, which is totally possible.

Anyhow, not trying to stir a pot, and not upset...just not what I expected. I picked up #1 on my list today, it's in my QT now. I only have two more on the list, the one's I've seen in LFS's frequently. The fourth, Blueline Angel, I learned is very seasonal and almost impossible to get outside of the summer months. So I'll see if maybe you can't get the last two on my list with this order. PM coming...
 

djkms

Reef Shark
M.A.S.C Club Member
#9
I hope there is no pot being stirred and if I came off as being rude or offensive I truly do apologize! It sounds like you are well on your way to doing this properly. Mixing angels can be very very difficult and does require a lot of research and patience and I think most just jump into it and fail, hence why i say the exception and not the rule (not implying that this is you by any means). I myself ultimately want a Angel and Butterfly mixed reef and it drives Will nuts LOL. Anytime we do a fish order I am always looking at getting more angels myself or picking up "reef caution" fish and do pick them up and Will always tells me "its going to eat your coral" and more often then not it does. It has been more common then not that every angel I get picks on certain types of coral. I love flame angels and have been through 4 so far this year just trying to get one that doesn't decimate my reef.

I do understand you frustration and want to touch on your points. Your first one is capacity and this in essence is still true. At this point we do have quite a few fish in our tanks and we are medicating some of them at this point. I am not sure how we are going to handle a fish order this week but I would assume a few fish are leaving this week to make room. Will never hastley makes decisions so I am sure he has a plan for this.

I know I did mention to you last week that it would probably be a month or 2 before we order again. Typically we order every couple of months because we do not "turn and burn" fish as I like to say. Our quarantine process is very lengthy and costly as every fish is dewormed (prazipro) and treated for any disease that may arise. We also take scale samples of the fish so we lesson the chance of potentially missing a disease because it was not seen by the naked eye. Anyways things do change and we do need to place another fish order this week. I was not expecting to place a order this soon to be honest that is why I mentioned a month or 2 before another order. When Will told me about placing a order you are the first person I thought about! Like I said, a Angel reef is ultimately one of my pursuits as well :)
 

ShelbyJK500

Dolphin
M.A.S.C Club Member
#10
Water under....

So, I think the main thing with attempting the feat is being prepared to remove/replace certain fish/angels if needed. I guess that is a hurdle many aren't willing to take or don't have the ability with a large enough sump or secondary tank should an issue arise. At least that's what I've gleaned through much of my reading. I'm willing to test out the waters (no pun) and see what might be successful for me. If it all falls apart, I may end up with one angel. ;) I'm not going to not try because many have failed to plan for success AND failure. I'm aiming for success, planning for either.

PM sent...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Top